How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker

This post contains links that, if you click on them and make a purchase, will earn me money. Regardless, I only recommend products or services that I believe will be good for my readers. Thanks for helping me continue to produce great content!

This post contains an affiliate link, for a NutriMill grain mill. If you were to purchase one, I’d earn a little something to help keep the lights on around here. But all opinions expressed in this post are STRICTLY my own. Just try and stop me from speaking my mind.


How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

I served my Creamy Homemade Polenta with Grilled Ratatouille – a grilled vegetable stew, of sorts.


I’ve learned to make polenta in my pressure cooker/multi-cooker, (for some of you, that’s an Instant Pot) and I will never go back to the old way I used to make polenta again! Making it in my electric pressure cooker is so much easier!  No more molten lava spatters on my hands or arms! No standing around stirring! 

I even considered titling this recipe “Polenta Without Pain”, but I was pretty sure no one would be googling that. But they SHOULD. Because that’s exactly what this recipe is: polenta that is neither painful to the appendages, nor a pain in the patootie.

Even if you’ve never tried making polenta the old fashioned way, you have GOT to try this method, if you have an Instant Pot, or some form of pressure cooker. You’re going to love how convenient, and most of all, how DELICIOUS this method is. I’m envisioning polenta being on my menu a LOT MORE this fall and winter, since I learned this simple method.

The pictures will tell the story. Because pretty much, there’s no story to tell. Just place the ingredients in the pressure cooker, seal it up and let it do its magic. Give it 10 minutes to release some pressure, and stir in some cheese, butter, and season to taste. Glory be! It’s a polenta miracle!!!

How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

Put the broth and the bay leaf into the pressure cooker.

How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

Add the salt.

How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

Take a picture of the bay leaf that’s been a-salted, because you can.

How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

Pour the ground cornmeal into the pool. Then whisk it around. Forget to add in the butter. (Don’t worry if you do that, like I did. It will turn out fine when you add the butter after it’s cooked.)

How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

Set it, and forget it it. Well, don’t FORGET forget it. But be happy that you don’t have to stand around and stir it for a half an hour and get splatter burns.

Ingredient Notes on Creamy Homemade Polenta:

The Cornmeal:

You can use store-bought stone ground cornmeal for this, any color: white or yellow. Your polenta will be wonderful. 

However,  I grind my own cornmeal in my brand new NutriMill Harvest. Cornmeal that’s freshly ground from popcorn (yes, popcorn!!!) tastes so fresh and sweet, you won’t believe the difference it makes in your cornbread or polenta.

My NutriMill Harvest is so pretty, I leave it out on my counter, all the time, which reminds me to use it more often, too. I adore it. I can’t believe how speedy it is, and how easy it is to operate.

Especially if you love grinding your own grains, or if you’re gluten free, you’re going to want to own one of these, yourself. My readers can get a special discount code, too, on the Nutrimill Harvest Everyday Essentials Package:   THATSUSANWILLIAMS-NM is my coupon code to save $29.98.

My recipe calls for 1 and 1/2 cups of cornmeal, and that’s how much popcorn I poured into the mill. As you can see in this picture, when you grind 1 1/2 cups of un-popped popcorn, you get more than 1 1/2 cups of ground cornmeal. I store the leftovers in a ziplock bag in my freezer, to use the next time I need cornmeal. Sometimes I use it to “bread” okra, when I fry okra. Sometimes I use it on my pizza pans, before I put the pizza crust onto them. It crisps up and adds texture and flavor to my crust. 

How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

See? If you grind 1 1/2 c. of popcorn, you’ll get a bit more cornmeal than you need. Maybe another 1/2 cup.

Cheese for Creamy Homemade Polenta

You can use whatever variety you’d like to, to change up the flavor. For my version I used havarti (because it’s creamy and melty) and freshly grated parmigiano reggiano, because it’s nutty and salty. 

How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

AFTER THE PRESSURE COOKING: Marvel at the swollen grains of cornmeal that have softened and absorbed that stock. Stir it around to make sure it’s smooth.

How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

Get cheesy with it. Whisk that cheese around till it melts. Sneak in the butter you forgot to add earlier, now, and hope for the best. All will be well. Taste it and add more salt & pepper, if you think it needs more seasoning.

How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

While the polenta is cooking in the pressure cooker, have your husband grill up some beautiful veggies. You’ll also need some roasted garlic, which was the very first thing I did to get this meal going: stuck a head of garlic in the oven to roast. But you could do it wrapped on foil on the grill, too.


At this point, you can probably safely call this dish either “cheese grits” or “polenta”. If you choose to identify it as cheese grits, in order to pacify someone you live with who complains regarding eating “fancy foods”, I’ll never tell. No one will be the wiser. In that case, you might want to serve these for breakfast or at an elegant brunch. They can be cooking while you pull the rest of your brunch together. How convenient is that?
Likewise, if you want to call it “polenta”, have an elegant Italian dinner, and serve this under Pork Osso Buco, that would be equally fitting. I chose to serve it under Grilled Ratatouille with Roasted Garlic, to use up some of the tomatoes and zucchini that have been finding their way into my kitchen. And it was heavenly! 

What If You Prefer Your Creamy Homemade Polenta Crispy?

Honestly, between the two, I’d have to say I prefer my polenta crispy. And that’s super easy to achieve. All you have to do is spread the polenta out on a rimmed cookie sheet, and let it cool in the fridge. You can do this with the entire batch of polenta, or with the leftover polenta, if you have enough. Since there were only two of us eating this meal, we had enough. 

We used a cookie cutter to cut out these neat cheesy circles from the chilled, and had them the next night, with the leftover grilled ratatouille veggies. Best leftovers EVER!!! Then you just brown them slowly in a little puddle of half olive oil, half butter. The butter brings that great buttery flavor and the olive oil prevents burning, as butter burns at a lower temp than olive oil. 

And because we had about 6 circles of leftover, unbrowned polenta left after that, we froze them! So that some winter evening, all I’ll need to do is stick a pan of chopped veggies in the oven to roast, and brown those little polenta circles up, for an elegant meal that will taste like I slaved hours over it. The anticipation of a good meal when I need it most makes me happy! 

How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

Have you EVER seen a better looking plate of LEFTOVERS????



How to Make Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker #creamy #cheesy #recipe #polenta #homemade #pressurecooker

PLEASE share this with your family, friends and neighbors! This image is perfect for pinning on Pinterest.

The Recipe for Creamy Homemade Polenta:

Creamy Homemade Polenta in a Pressure Cooker
Deliciously creamy homemade Polenta, cooked in a pressure cooker/multicooker.
Write a review
  1. 5 c. chicken stock
  2. 1 1/2 c. stone ground cornmeal
  3. 3/4 t. sea salt
  4. 1 bay leaf
  5. 3 T. butter
  6. 3 oz. Havarti, or other soft, melty cheese
  7. 4 oz. freshly grated Parmigiano Reggiano
  1. Stir all the ingredients, except the last two cheeses into the pressure cooker, and cook on high pressure for 15 minutes.
  2. Allow the pressure to release naturally, and then uncover and stir vigorously to break up any clumps. Add the cheese, and stir some more. Let the polenta sit 5 or 10 minutes, to fully absorb all the liquid. If it's too thick, you can add some more hot chicken stock, or milk, or even water.
  1. Don't forget: you can crisp this up by spreading any leftovers on a rimmed cookie sheet and refrigerating it. Then cut into whatever shapes you desire. A heart would be nice for Valentine's Day! And let it crisp up in a small puddle of butter and olive oil in a cast iron skillet.
Adapted from Melissa Clark's Dinner in an Instant
Adapted from Melissa Clark's Dinner in an Instant
That Susan Williams

Speak Your Mind