Skip to Content

Expensive Steak House Taste at a Fraction of the Price

This post contains links that, if you click on them and make a purchase, will earn me money. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. . Regardless, I only recommend products or services that I believe will be good for my readers. Thanks for helping me continue to produce great content!

This post, Expensive Steak House Taste at a Fraction of the Price, will give you all the information you need to achieve that goal, via the processes of dry aging, salting, and using a compound butter on your next piece of choice meat.

The perfect medium rare steak: expensive steak house taste, at a fraction of the price.

The joy that is set before you: expensive steak house taste, at a fraction of the price. Thanks to dry aging, salting, and a lovely compound butter.

Have you ever eaten out at a fancy steak house, and wondered why the steak you grill at home never tastes quite as magnificent as the one you got at that expensive steak house? Disappointing, isn’t it?

We had the best steak we’ve ever eaten in our own home the other night, the kind you hope to get when you pay the big bucks, to eat out at a steak house! The flavor was fantastic! Our steaks had the same amazing flavor and tenderness – that steak house taste – that we’ve had only at fine dining establishments. And all it took was a few secrets: secrets that you, too, can use to produce the best steak you’ve ever grilled!

I’m going to share with you what I’ve learned. And if you’re wondering just what those secrets are, they have to do with: dry-aging, salting, and compound butter.


Steak House Meat: Prime Vs. Choice

The first thing you need to know is that the grade of beef that is served in expensive steak houses is different than what we buy in our local grocery stores. A fine steak house or hotel offers Prime beef, which is not , for the most part, available in most grocery stores. You CAN find it, but only 2% of all beef produced in this country is designated as Prime.  Mostly, you find Choice beef, not Prime, for sale at your local grocery store.

There are two things that set Prime Beef apart from Choice: marbling and maturity. Prime beef is more heavily marbled than choice. Marbling means fat. And more fat = more flavor. Secondly, Prime beef comes from younger animals. Less maturity = more tenderness.
Prime beef is more expensive than Choice. Much more expensive. But it honestly is worth the money! Unfortunately, my husband and I have champagne tastes and a malt liquor budget. So, we decided to see what we could do to a Choice cut of beef that would give it its best hope of tasting like a Prime steak. What else do steak houses do that makes their steaks taste so great?

A Steak House Uses Dry-Aging

Other than using prime beef, expensive steak houses will typically use beef that has been dry aged. Here’s what we learned about dry-aging. Dry-aging steaks gives them a better flavor and texture. When moisture evaporates from the beef through the process of dry-aging, the fat becomes more concentrated. We also learned that dry-aging triggers the breakdown of muscle proteins in the beef, giving the steak a dense, more tender texture. The peptides and amino acids that form as the muscle proteins are breaking down impart a smokier flavor to the steak.
Because of an article we read in Cooks Illustrated, we wanted to try dry aging our beef at home. We bought 3 really thick T-bone steaks, Choice grade,  from Costco. When I say really thick, I’d estimate they were about 1  1/2″ in thickness. We wrapped the steaks in cheesecloth to prevent excessive dehydration, and put them on a rack (for air circulation) that had been placed inside a jelly roll pan, placing them in the bottom of the fridge, which is the coldest part.
(Yes, one challenge you might find – it was a challenge for me, at least – is cleaning out the real estate in your fridge to make room for a cookie sheet filled with a single layer of moo. So, that could be something to plan/work around.)
Next, we left them there for 4 days. Not a quick fix meal. So…something else to plan around. But, hey, it gave me all week to look forward to eating them.


The next step we took was called “salting”. Which is exactly what it sounds like. Why do this? Well, when salt is applied to meat, it draws the juices from the meat to the surface, initially, but then, the briny solution that forms from the meat juices + the salt itself gets drawn back deep down into the meat. This imparts that wonderful flavor all the way down into the depths of the steak.
The steak surface benefits as well, as a nice crust is formed while the steak is cooking. As you will see, we sprinkled our steaks liberally with kosher salt. Steaks need to be salted about 1 hour prior to cooking. About 3/4 of a teaspoon of salt per 8 ounces of meat will do nicely. Take the steaks out of the fridge, remove and discard the cheesecloth, and apply the salt evenly over the surface, and let rest at room temperature for an hour before grilling it. Immediately before grilling our steaks, my husband rinsed the salt off the surface, and then patted them completely dry with paper towels.

We grilled those steaks to a temperature of around 133º, and then took them off the grill. This produced the steak you see here, which we would call medium rare. The temperature of the meat rose to 140º after coming off the grill.

Compound Butter

The third thing we did was use a compound butter. Compound butters are nothing new: James Beard was recommending them back in the day. My Mom used to make a garlic butter for the steaks we ate nearly every summer Saturday night when I was growing up. (Those steaks that on their own tasted of lighter fluid, but when doctored with Mom’s garlic butter? Mmmmm!)
And you can make one as simply as smashing up a garlic clove, and putting it in a half a stick of melted butter, the way my Mom did it. And that will be fabulous. Or you can try something like what I did last night, which was sautéing a minced shallot with some thyme and pepper and a minced clove of garlic thrown in at the last minute, in a bit of butter. Let that cool to room temp, and then mix it in with a half a stick of softened butter, and put a blop of that on each steak. It’s not an exact science. I’d encourage you to try whatever you think your family might enjoy, in terms of which herb you like. Parsley would be fantastic, too. Or chives. Or rosemary.
If you get the potential that compound butters offer, be sure to check out my post on Grilled Halibut with Cilantro Lime Compound Butter. It’s one of the easiest things to do when when you’re grilling fish, and it’s a positive flavor bomb!

Picture time!

Day One of dry aging. Note the cheesecloth.


Day 3 of Dry-Aging.


Day Four of Dry-Aging, before salting.

Salted: one hour and a half before grilling.
Salted: One hour and a half after salting. Note that quite a bit of the salt has been drawn in.

How about the perfect bottle of wine to accompany these succulent steaks? I have the very thing!
A wine tutorial for choosing the perfect bottle for this very recipe.
How to Get Expensive Steak House Taste at a Fraction of the Price, through Dry Aging, Salting, and Compound Butter #steak #beef #dryage #dryagedbeef #dryagingsteaks

Do me a HUGE favor and share this: whether on Reddit, Facebook, Twitter, or Pinterest.

If you think this is share-worthy, tweet-worthy, Pin-worthy or stumble-worthy, then, share it, pin it, tweet your heart out, or stumble away! I’d be ever so grateful!


Monday 27th of February 2017

I want to try this but can't see all of your blog post. Tried it on two different browsers so I'm thinking it's not me, but then everyone on the thread before me seems to have read it okay.

Susan Williams

Tuesday 28th of February 2017

I noticed the other day on Mobile that it was awkwardly formatted, so I changed the formatting a bit, Brenda. If you come back to it, hopefully you'll be able to see it now. Thanks for letting me know!

Ellen Dolgen

Saturday 25th of February 2017

I never knew how to age a steak. I doesn't seem that difficult. I shall def try this. Thanks so much for the tips!


Saturday 25th of February 2017

I shared this all over the place because my hubs loves to cook steak and these are great tips!!

Susan Williams

Saturday 25th of February 2017

Thank you so much!!! I really appreciate the shares!


Saturday 25th of February 2017

Those steaks look delicious! I am going to definitely give these a try very soon.

Sandra Sallin

Monday 23rd of June 2014

Great description on dry aging. Must try this. Thanks.